Skip to content

hot off the satellite, why technology erodes choice

June 29, 2010

The world is becoming a much more complex place in which to inhabit, or should I say to exist. I am not talking about the effects and beneficial gains from the technology revolution, we have experienced revolutions before, the industrial revolution rocked the very foundations of our society and yet despite the enormous upheaval and the predictions of that again the end is nigh we emerged more prosperous, engaged and with a wide-eyed anticipation of what the future held for us.

The technological revolution has like its predecessor the industrial revolution produced many fundamental changes to our society. Technology has opened the world up, it has made travelling easier, faster and more efficient, and it has also allowed us the luxury of almost instant communication to anyone anywhere in the world. The gadgets from the mobile phone, computers and GPS have made a our life’s experiences vastly different from those of even a persons of a mere 40 years ago.

I however think that one achievement stands above all others as the single most important achievement of all that both the industrial and technological revolution has allowed. I am referring too, the ability to break free from the constraints of our very planet and the gravity that binds us here and to explore the solar system and beyond. However it is in space or more specifically the small zone of space that extends out only a mere hundred or so kilometres from earth, the area that is inhabited by the myriad of satellites in orbit around our planet that has had the most profound effect on mankind. The ability to launch ourselves and our payloads from the planet and defy gravity to remain in obit above the earth has allowed us to lay one of the most pivotal foundations of our society. It has allowed the ubiquitous communication to almost any destination in the world unlike any other human advancement before.

All revolutions have costs be they real implied or intangible, of course they most certainly have benefits or else I suspect mankind would not have progressed down that path. Time is a dimension, and like the three others that we live with, height, length and depth, we are constrained by the laws the governor it. We can only see the 4th dimension as a point in time the present, and although we are aware of the progression of time, and write of our experiences in our history, and although we can also look to the future with optimism our path is only forward. The effects of all revolutions past are accumulative, and as we live through this the current one it will apply many more costs to our already burden ridden lives.

But what are these costs?  What is it that I refer too? I really should refer to them as what they really are the “unintended consequences”; these are the costs that revolutions have burdened us with and one consequence in particular concerns me the most.

I think that we are losing choice, no not the ability to choose what we will consume, a simple trip to the supermarket, a brief moment on the internet or the simple act of turning the television should more that adequately illustrate that we are definitely not wanting for choice, it abounds everywhere. No I refer to the choice to either obey a rule, a regulation or law; I don’t want to live in a world where it is impossible to break the law.

Don’t get me wrong I did not say I want to break the law, no not at all. It’s just every new law, combined with the use of new technology in the fight against crime corrodes at our ultimate freedom, free will. This may sound counter intuitive but as we corrupt technology and apply it to maintaining law and order we are creating an all-encompassing gaol for mankind to inhabit. We will no longer be able to break the law.

This is a complex concept, a subject that I have thought long and hard about, I suppose the embryonic seeds of the this idea/belief first surfaced many years ago when as a young man I read 1984 by George Orwell, and further readings of science fiction cemented the fear. I know that these are not books of prediction, but as an observer of the mankind and the advancement of technology I see its effects on mankind and society, I see many troubling parallels.

I will endeavour to provide a couple of explicit examples of the chilling effect that this is happening on society. I don’t intend this to be a doom piece no matter how it sounds. No this is a warning, a warning that we as a society needs to address the constant ratcheting up of rules and regulations or as I alluded too gaols will become the confinement area of the purpose-built correctional facility that binds, us a place we will  know as society.

The first areas of law enforcement that seemed to embrace the technological advances all appear to be in the areas of traffic management. This was really a no brainer and such an easy sell to the public. Motor Vehicle incidents are one of mankind greatest preventable killer of human beans. The cost on society is huge and the suffering and hurt thrust upon the victims of these incidents can be psychologically, financially and physically crippling. Is it any wonder why governments acted and yes I agree technology can most definitely help in reducing the carnage, but what I see goes far beyond this. I believe and I know will be shouted down by governments as ignoring the facts, but revenue drives this and OK or as a consequence we raise revenue. The proliferation of speed and red like cameras is so vast and ever-expanding that I can see a day where is will be impossible to break any road laws without being caught, fined and if it serves the government’s agenda humiliated as a law-breaker, mind you not so serious as to require incarceration after all you can’t contribute if your locked up.

This may seem far-fetched but think about it, those satellites that I talked of they run the GPS system the earth loves so much, and yes no doubt one day every car will have one, it could even be mandated. These devices are able to record you speed and could in time remotely report breaches’ to law enforcement authorities. This will happen you may dismiss the “unintended consequences” as the law at work I just don’t and see it as a willing away of another freedom of ours.

Governments all try to control us for a variety of reasons and many different social models exist around the world, however there is universal condemnation of undemocratic governments and the control they wield upon their people. Prior to the invention of printing press, non personal communication was afforded to only the  powerful and the wealthy, governments of course utilized this, they were epitome of wealth and power and this monopoly power consumed them. The advent of the book opened up society to the power of expression and the sharing of ideas. It empowered the people and the governments hit back with a new and improved sword to cut away at the freedom that wide spread freedom and expression of ideas allowed they introduced censorship. Jump ahead today and the situation has not much changed. The politically corrupt regimes still exert their absolute control over the people, they now utilise computer technology to beat the technology that could allow their people the freedom that we the peoples of the world’s so-called free nations are all accorded. Yes the world still condemns them for their lack of freedoms but it would appear many nations must secretly admire the absolute control these regimes exercise else why else would they look to replicate and copy the censorship that permeates these regimes.

There has been a debate just recently with the Australian Federal Government poised to introduce a mandatory filter to block refused classification material from all Australian residents; this is done with the aim to protect Australians from the so-called nasties that are lurking just beyond our borders. However I see this as just another claw back of power, a stifling of our freedoms and that if not challenged will enviably lead to scope creep and again those dreaded “unintended consequences”

There are multitude of everyday items that are being corrupted in the name of law and order. We are have become a monitored society, every thing you do, every where you go can be recorded and monitored. Every detail of your life lives on a database some where, the government or really just about anyone if truly connected can obtain information on every facet of your life, in most cases you have volunteered this information but in may cases it is surreptitiously recorded. These days it would appear the only real area the only sanctuary that is truly private is your home. But alas and ignore the pun but the majority of us have added a new window that allows us to peer out at the world via the internet unfortunately this too comes with an “unintended consequences” as not only is it a window on the world but it works two ways, it is also a portal in, and although we think only we have the keys to the lock, other very resourceful people have them too.

Its not a stretch to one day governments mandating this be a two-way portal that allows them access, after all I just heard The US President was just presented with the master keys to the internet. Many that argue for greater government control often provide this statement as a rebuttal to any questioning of these or similar articles “you have nothing to fear if you have nothing to hide”.

Well I will counter with that I have plenty to fear if I live in a world where defiance to the rule of law, every misstep, every illegal act is detected, fined and deterred, if I am powerless to break the rules I really have no freedom at all. I believe the ability to do the right thing, the ethical thing is a choice and choice is really the only freedom, remove that and I might as well be in a goal.

So in conclusion although I think satellites have allowed the innovation and fulfilment of so many gadgets that offer so many amazing benefits to mankind and that I stand by my assertion that space exploration and the lessons learned have allowed for many of these great achievements, it’s just I see the “unintended consequences” this time as having a far great impact in the erosion of our rights than any other advancement in technology or knowledge has ever been before.

What do you think? Have I lost the plot? The one thing that I must say that I am thankful for, I like the window on to the world that satellites, the internet and technology allows me and the ability to freely post my thoughts, feel free to share yours leave a comment, I would love to hear from you.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: